PSARC/2008/549 - Apache Standard C++ Library

[John Fischer]

PSARC,

Sorry I missed the meeting today.  I had to cover a Solaris P-Team
meeting for my organization.  I'll work with Stefan and Steve Clamage
to resolve issues.

Thanks,

John

Garrett D'Amore wrote:
> I'm not sure if members of other ARCs (LSARC) can derail PSARC cases.  
> If so, then no problem here.  If not, please take this message as 
> indicating that I am derailing this case (in other words, if John can't 
> derail it, then I can.)
> 
> As one of the more vociferous detractors for this case, it probably 
> would be a good idea to CC me on the conversation between Stefan and Steve.
> 
>    -- Garrett
> 
> John Plocher wrote:
>> John Plocher wrote on the 26th of September:
>>> I'm really disappointed that the compiler team hasn't jumped in to this
>>> discussion.  Have they been contacted and invited?
>>
>> I just got the following from Steve Clamage, one of the lead engineers
>> on the compiler team:
>>
>>> I was only today made aware of this PSARC case, and I would like to
>>> derail the fast-track if it is not too late. I knew the topic was
>>> being discussed, and contributed negative comments to those who
>>> mentioned it to me. In short, I think the proposal is 
>>> counter-productive,
>>> makes false statements of fact, and will not (and cannot) have the
>>> good effects it claims.
>>
>> Please consider this fasttrack case derailed.  The next step is for 
>> Stefan
>> and Steve to get together [somewhere not on the PSARC aliases] and 
>> discuss
>> these issues, and to then come back with their resolutions and/or an 
>> updated
>> proposal.
>>
>>   -John
>>
>>
>